What to Look for in a 3PL

Faith Artieda • July 6, 2026

Choosing a third-party logistics (3PL) provider is one of the most important decisions a growing brand can make. The right partner doesn't just ship orders—they become an extension of your business, helping you scale operations, navigate retail requirements, and create a better customer experience.


Faith Artieda, spoke with Scott Hothem, Senior Vice President of Customer Solutions, who has spent more than 14 years helping brands find logistics solutions that support long-term growth. From omnichannel fulfillment to choosing the right fulfillment partner, Scott shares what every business should know before selecting a 3PL.


A 3PL Should Be More Than a Warehouse

When companies begin searching for a fulfillment provider, many focus on the basics: warehouse locations, pricing, or square footage.

While those factors matter, Scott believes they don't tell the whole story.


"Every 3PL has warehouses, forklifts, and scanners," he explains. "The real question is whether they understand your business."

A great logistics partner takes the time to understand your products, order profiles, customers, growth plans, and operational challenges before proposing a solution. Rather than offering a one-size-fits-all pricing sheet, they build a fulfillment strategy tailored to your business.


At Barrett, that consultative approach has helped brands of all sizes successfully navigate periods of rapid growth and operational change.


Why Omnichannel Experience Matters

Today's brands rarely sell through just one channel.


A customer may place an order through your Shopify store, while another purchases the same product on Amazon. At the same time, your largest retailer may submit a purchase order for thousands of units destined for stores across the country.

Managing those channels requires more than warehouse space—it requires operational expertise.


Scott explains that omnichannel fulfillment means seamlessly managing direct-to-consumer orders alongside wholesale and retail distribution while maintaining inventory accuracy, retailer compliance, and exceptional customer service.


For brands expanding into retailers like Walmart, Target, Costco, or Nordstrom, choosing a 3PL with proven retail experience can help avoid costly compliance issues, chargebacks, and fulfillment delays.


Ask the Right Questions Before Choosing a 3PL

Instead of asking only about rates, Scott recommends asking prospective logistics providers questions like:


  • Have you worked with companies similar to ours?
  • How have you helped customers overcome growth challenges?
  • Can your operations scale with our business?
  • What retail partners do you currently support?
  • What technology and reporting capabilities do you offer?
  • How do you approach onboarding new customers?

These conversations reveal far more about a provider's capabilities than pricing alone.


The best 3PL relationships are built on transparency, collaboration, and shared goals—not simply transactional services.


Price Is Important—But Value Matters More

Every business wants competitive pricing, but the lowest quote isn't always the best investment.


According to Scott, fulfillment pricing should reflect the complexity of a customer's operation—not a generic menu of services.


Factors like SKU count, order volume, value-added services, inventory requirements, seasonality, and retail compliance all influence the most effective fulfillment solution.


It's one reason Barrett develops customized proposals instead of standardized rate sheets.


Scott notes that Barrett frequently reconnects with companies that initially selected a lower-cost provider only to discover that their fulfillment partner couldn't support their evolving business needs.


Look for a Partner That Can Grow With You

Growth is exciting—but it also introduces new operational challenges.


A startup shipping a few hundred ecommerce orders today may find itself fulfilling thousands of daily orders or shipping to major retailers within a few years.


Scott has seen that transformation firsthand.


Over the years, Barrett has partnered with emerging brands from their earliest stages, helping many grow into nationally recognized companies generating hundreds of millions of dollars in annual revenue.


That kind of long-term partnership is possible because Barrett focuses on building solutions that scale—not solutions that only solve today's challenges.


Technology Should Enhance the Customer Experience

Artificial intelligence has become one of the biggest conversations in logistics.


While Barrett continues investing in automation, systems integrations, data analytics, and emerging technologies, Scott believes technology should enhance—not replace—the customer relationship.


For Barrett, meaningful conversations still matter.


When prospective customers reach out, they're connected with experienced professionals who understand fulfillment strategy, supply chain challenges, and operational execution—not an automated chatbot.


Technology should make service better. It shouldn't replace the people behind it.


Barrett's Biggest Competitive Advantage: Its People

Throughout the conversation, one theme surfaced again and again: people.


After more than 80 years in business, Barrett has built its reputation on experienced employees, long-term customer relationships, and a culture centered on continuous improvement.


From warehouse associates to executive leadership, every team member plays a role in delivering exceptional customer experiences.


That people-first mindset has helped Barrett build lasting partnerships with brands across apparel, health and beauty, consumer products, food and beverage, and other industries while continuing to invest in technology, facilities, and operational excellence.


Final Thoughts

Choosing a 3PL isn't simply about finding a warehouse—it's about finding a partner that understands your business, supports your growth, and shares your commitment to customer success.


As Scott Hothem shared in this first edition of Inside Barrett, companies should look beyond pricing and ask deeper questions about experience, scalability, technology, and culture.


Because when your logistics partner succeeds, your business has the opportunity to do the same.


Stay tuned for future editions of Inside Barrett with Faith Artieda, where we'll continue introducing the experts behind Barrett Distribution Centers and answering the logistics questions that matter most to growing brands.

Recent Blog Posts

By Katherine Wroth • October 29, 2026
Activewear brand founded by “The Real Housewives of New York City” star Erika Hammond now shipping orders from Barrett’s Somerset, N.J., facility
Four Peaks, One Partner: An Inside Look at How Barrett Scales With SCOUT, Every Peak
By Megan Krauss • October 23, 2026
The Results Most brands brace for one peak season a year. The holidays hit, volume spikes and everyone holds their breath until January. SCOUT Bags does it four times. Yes, that's right, four times... Through every launch, SCOUT has maintained 99.6% DTC on-time shipping. That's while moving 120,000+ units in a two-week window and keeping the rest of the business running.
By Faith Artieda • October 23, 2026
FRANKLIN, Mass., Aug. 11, 2026 — Barrett Distribution Centers , a leading third-party logistics provider specializing in eCommerce fulfillment, announced a new partnership with PAHI Footwear , an emerging footwear and wellness brand focused on balance, stability and confidence. Barrett is providing omnichannel warehousing, fulfillment and managed transportation services from its Memphis fulfillment campus to support PAHI's direct-to-consumer, independent retail and mass retail channels. "As a growing brand, choosing the right fulfillment partner was a big decision for us," said Luke Schapfel , logistics manager at PAHI. "From the beginning, Barrett took the time to understand our business and where we're headed. Their team was responsive, easy to work with and genuinely invested in helping us build the right foundation for growth. That gave us confidence we had the right partner." The implementation began in late 2025 with a phased rollout. Barrett first onboarded PAHI's direct-to-consumer (D2C) business before expanding support to independent retailers and national retail partners throughout the second and third quarters of 2026. "Barrett has a successful history working with emerging apparel and footwear brands and helping them scale across omnichannel programs," said Scott Hothem , senior vice president of customer solutions at Barrett. "We're excited to support PAHI as it builds its presence in the U.S. market from our Memphis fulfillment campus. We look forward to helping the brand grow across both direct-to-consumer and retail channels." Barrett currently supports approximately 500 SKUs of men's and women's footwear for PAHI across direct-to-consumer, independent retail and mass retail channels. The partnership provides PAHI with a scalable fulfillment foundation as the brand continues to grow across channels. About PAHI Footwear PAHI was born from a simple yet powerful vision: to create footwear that combines comfort, innovation, and stability. The brand was founded to meet the growing need for footwear that offers not only style but also balance and support, empowering people to move with confidence throughout their daily lives. Drawing inspiration from the 5000-year-old twin-hull boat technology, PAHI introduced the P.O.R.T. system, revolutionizing how shoes provide balance. About Barrett Distribution Centers Since 1941, Barrett has provided customized third-party logistics (3PL), direct-to-consumer (DTC) eCommerce fulfillment, omnichannel distribution, managed transportation solutions and retail compliance for clients across all industries, with a focus on apparel & footwear, health & beauty, consumer packaged goods (CPG) and education. Barrett continues to be a leading 3rd party logistics provider in North America, known for superior execution, customer engagement and direct access to senior leadership decision makers. As a member of Inc's fastest growing companies list 15+ times, Barrett is big enough to do the job and still small enough to deeply care about your business. Brands interested in a new 3PL partnership may contact Barrett directly here . Media Contact: Faith Artieda Marketing Content Specialist faith.artieda@barrettdistribution.com
More Posts