Why So Many 3PL Searches Fail (And How Growing Brands Can Get It Right)

Faith Artieda • June 12, 2026

Recently, Barrett Distribution Centers hosted a webinar with Fulfill.com Co-Founders Joe Spisak and Dan White to discuss one of the most important decisions a growing brand can make: choosing the right third-party logistics (3PL) partner.

Drawing on years of experience helping thousands of ecommerce brands evaluate, select, and transition to fulfillment providers, the conversation explored why so many 3PL searches fail, common mistakes brands make during the evaluation process, and the red flags and green flags that can help companies make better logistics decisions.

The discussion featured candid insights from Joe and Dan, alongside Barrett's Vice President of Sales & Marketing, Bryan Corbett, who shared perspectives from nearly two decades in the logistics industry. Together, they covered everything from pricing transparency and onboarding expectations to operational fit, scalability, and the role relationships play in long-term fulfillment success.

Whether you're searching for your first 3PL or evaluating a new partner to support your next stage of growth, these takeaways can help you avoid costly mistakes and build a stronger logistics strategy.

The Challenge: Finding the Right 3PL Isn't Easy

When brands realize they've outgrown self-fulfillment, they're faced with a seemingly endless list of options. They can conduct their own search, hire a consultant, rely on referrals, or work with a fulfillment matchmaking service.

The problem isn't a lack of options—it's knowing which option is actually right for your business.

As Joe Spisak explained:

"You go to Google and type in best fulfillment company for your company. You kind of get hit with the same 10, 20, 30 different 3PLs that are sponsoring Google ads."

With thousands of logistics providers in the market, visibility doesn't necessarily equal capability. The best fulfillment partner for one brand may be completely wrong for another.

That's why Bryan Corbett emphasized a simple but important point:

"The best people find the best 3PLs for the brands that they're servicing."

The objective isn't finding the biggest name or the cheapest quote. It's finding the provider that best aligns with your products, channels, growth plans, and customer expectations.

Why Price Shouldn't Drive the Decision

One of the most common mistakes brands make during a 3PL search is focusing too heavily on pricing.

While fulfillment costs matter, the panel agreed that operational failures often cost far more than paying slightly higher rates.

Spisak shared a personal example from his time running an ecommerce business:"One of the board gaming companies almost went bankrupt during the holiday season when we got really, really messed over by one of our 3PLs. We lost hundreds of thousands of dollars."

The experience ultimately led him to launch his own fulfillment operation before later founding Fulfill.com.

The lesson is simple: selecting a logistics partner based solely on price can create far greater costs down the road through inventory issues, service failures, customer dissatisfaction, and lost sales.

The Biggest Red Flags During a 3PL Search

The panel discussed several warning signs brands should watch for when evaluating potential logistics partners.

1. Quotes Before Discovery

A fulfillment provider that offers pricing before understanding your business should raise concerns.

As Spisak noted:

"If a 3PL is just ripping a quote right back, there's so much more that goes into proper pricing."

Order profiles, SKU counts, inventory characteristics, sales channels, packaging requirements, return volumes, and retailer compliance requirements all influence fulfillment costs.

Without discovery, pricing is often little more than a guess.

2. Salespeople Who Say Yes to Everything

Dan White highlighted another common issue:

"How many times have I seen a salesperson at a 3PL say, 'We can do that, no problem,' without even asking a question?"

Experienced logistics operators know that every fulfillment operation has unique challenges. Providers that promise immediate solutions without asking detailed questions may be prioritizing closing the deal rather than ensuring long-term success.

3. Overly Complex Pricing Structures

Opaque fee structures can make it difficult to understand the true cost of outsourcing fulfillment.

Spisak shared:"I've seen 3PLs with 100-plus line item quotes, which is ridiculous."

Brands should understand exactly how storage, fulfillment, transportation, accessorials, and value-added services are priced before signing any agreement.

Green Flags That Signal a Strong Partnership

Just as important as spotting warning signs is recognizing the characteristics of a high-quality fulfillment partner.

Meet More Than the Sales Team

Corbett encouraged brands to look beyond the salesperson during the evaluation process.

The people responsible for running your account day-to-day will have a much greater impact on your success than the person who signed the contract. Strong providers are comfortable introducing operational leaders early because they view fulfillment as a long-term partnership—not simply a sales transaction.

Visit the Facility

Nothing replaces seeing an operation firsthand.

A warehouse visit provides valuable insight into:

Operational organization
Inventory management practices
Employee engagement
Technology deployment
Quality control processes
Safety standards

As the discussion highlighted, brands often learn more from walking a facility than they do from reviewing a proposal.

Look for Similar Customers

One of the best indicators of success is whether a 3PL already supports companies with similar requirements.

According to Spisak:"Find a 3PL that is shipping for other companies similar to you."

A provider experienced in handling comparable products, order volumes, and fulfillment channels is often better positioned to deliver a successful onboarding and long-term partnership.

Why Relationships Matter More Than Most People Realize

Technology, automation, analytics, and reporting continue to reshape the logistics industry. Yet despite these advancements, fulfillment remains a people-driven business.

Even the best-run operations occasionally face challenges. The difference between a temporary issue and a failed partnership often comes down to communication, trust, and collaboration.

Organizations that build strong relationships between account management teams, warehouse leadership, and client stakeholders are better equipped to navigate problems when they arise.

The Right 3PL Today May Not Be the Right 3PL Tomorrow

Another major theme from the discussion was scalability.

As brands grow, fulfillment requirements become more complex.

Joe Spisak explained:"The right 3PL for a $1 million ARR brand may not be the right 3PL for a $10 million ARR brand."

As businesses expand, they often add:

Amazon FBA and FBM programs
Retail distribution
EDI integrations
Omnichannel fulfillment
Multiple warehouse locations
International shipping requirements

The best logistics partners don't just solve today's challenges. They have the infrastructure, technology, and expertise to support tomorrow's growth as well.

Final Takeaway: Focus on Fit, Not Just Features

There is no universal "best" 3PL.

There is only the best-fit 3PL for your business.

Successful fulfillment partnerships are built on operational alignment, transparent communication, scalability, and trust. Brands that invest time in discovery, ask deeper questions, visit facilities, and evaluate long-term fit are far more likely to achieve fulfillment success.

As the webinar made clear, choosing a 3PL isn't simply a procurement decision—it's a strategic partnership that can directly impact customer experience, profitability, and growth.

The brands that get it right aren't looking for the lowest quote.

They're looking for the right partner.

< Older Post

Recent Blog Posts

Delta Galil Selects Barrett Distribution Centers for Bare Necessities and Organic Basics Fulfillment Operations

By Katherine Wroth • June 9, 2026

FRANKLIN, Mass.— Barrett Distribution Centers , a third-party logistics provider specializing in eCommerce and omnichannel fulfillment, announced the successful transition of fulfillment operations for Delta Galil USA’s Bare Necessities and Organic Basics brands. The project included the deployment of a 100,000-square-foot operation within Barrett’s Forney, Texas facility, and was completed on an accelerated implementation timeline. "When our previous provider announced it was discontinuing operations, we had a very short window to transition two established brands without disrupting the customer experience," said Mike Irrgang , vice president of operations at Delta Galil Industries. "Barrett came highly recommended. After visiting the Forney facility, we were confident they had the capacity, expertise and urgency needed to support the transition. Their team delivered on every commitment, helping us successfully transition more than 1.6 million units and 100,000+ SKUs within just four weeks." Barrett supports a robust portfolio of apparel, footwear and lifestyle brands, helping growing brands scale efficiently through customized fulfillment solutions. "At Barrett, we know every new customer startup can be stressful, but our team of project managers, operations, customer service and IT professionals have seen it all." said Scott Hothem , senior vice president of customer solutions at Barrett. "Our teams worked closely together to develop a transition plan, proactively solve challenges as they arose, while keeping the project plan on track. We're proud to have delivered a successful outcome during a rapid transition and look forward to supporting the business for years to come." The successful implementation highlights Barrett's expertise in apparel fulfillment and its ability to execute complex transitions on accelerated timelines. About Delta Galil Delta Galil is a global leader in intimates and activewear, a high-tech apparel company harnessing the power of innovation and technology to create next-generation products. Founded in 1975 in Tel Aviv, Delta Galil has offices, factories, and retail locations around the world, from New York to Los Angeles, Tel Aviv to London, Cairo to Shanghai. Synonymous with cutting-edge innovation and next-level design, Delta Galil owns several leading brands and is a sought-after partner to the iconic, the disruptive and the digitally native. About Barrett Distribution Centers Since 1941, Barrett has provided customized third-party logistics (3PL), direct-to-consumer (DTC) eCommerce fulfillment, omnichannel distribution, managed transportation solutions and retail compliance for clients across all industries, with a focus on apparel & footwear, health & beauty, consumer packaged goods (CPG) and education. Barrett continues to be a leading 3rd party logistics provider in North America, known for superior execution, customer engagement and direct access to senior leadership decision makers. As a member of Inc's fastest growing companies list 15+ times, Barrett is big enough to do the job and still small enough to deeply care about your business. Brands interested in a new 3PL partnership may contact Barrett directly here . Official Release Here

Behind the Scenes of Ecommerce Fulfillment: From Warehouse Shelf to Doorstep

By Faith Artieda • June 4, 2026

Behind the Scenes of Ecommerce Fulfillment: From Warehouse Shelf to Doorstep When a customer clicks "Buy Now," they expect a simple outcome: the right product arrives on time and in perfect condition. What they don't see is the complex fulfillment operation working behind the scenes to make that experience possible. For ecommerce brands, every shipment represents more than an order. It's a promise to a customer. Whether it's a rug, a beauty product, a piece of apparel, or a food item, fulfillment has a direct impact on customer satisfaction, reviews, repeat purchases, and brand reputation. At Barrett Distribution Centers, we help brands deliver on that promise every day. Recently, our team captured the journey of a Tumble rug moving through one of our fulfillment operations. While the process may appear seamless from the outside, each order is supported by a combination of technology, inventory management, quality controls, and experienced warehouse professionals working together to ensure accuracy and efficiency. Great Fulfillment Starts Long Before an Order Is Placed The customer experience doesn't begin when someone clicks "Buy." It begins with how inventory is received, organized, tracked, and managed inside the warehouse. Accurate inventory is the foundation of successful fulfillment. If inventory data is unreliable, every downstream process becomes more difficult. That's why Barrett invests heavily in inventory control processes, warehouse management technology, and operational discipline. From receiving and putaway to cycle counting and inventory audits, every step is designed to maintain visibility and accuracy across our customers' inventory. When an order enters the system, our teams know exactly where inventory is located and how to process it efficiently. Technology Creates Visibility—People Create Results Modern fulfillment requires sophisticated technology, but technology alone doesn't create a great customer experience. Warehouse management systems, automation tools, and integrated data platforms help drive efficiency and visibility. They provide real-time information, streamline workflows, and help teams prioritize work throughout the day. However, successful fulfillment still depends on people. The warehouse associates, supervisors, quality teams, customer experience professionals, and operations leaders behind every shipment are what transform data into execution. At Barrett, our focus has always been on combining technology with operational expertise. The result is a fulfillment process designed to scale while maintaining high service levels and accuracy. Quality Control Is Built Into Every Order Customers rarely think about quality control when they receive a package. That's because the best quality processes are often invisible. Before an order leaves the warehouse, multiple checkpoints help ensure products are picked correctly, packaged appropriately, and prepared for shipment according to customer requirements. These controls are especially important for brands that have worked hard to create a premium customer experience. The condition of a product upon arrival can significantly impact how customers perceive a brand. A damaged shipment or incorrect order doesn't just create operational costs—it can erode customer trust. That's why quality isn't treated as a final inspection. It's embedded throughout the fulfillment process. Every Package Represents a Brand Third-party logistics providers don't own the brands they serve, but they play a critical role in protecting those brands. For many consumers, the delivery experience is one of the few physical interactions they have with an ecommerce company. Packaging quality, order accuracy, delivery speed, and shipment visibility all contribute to the overall brand experience. When a Tumble rug arrives at a customer's doorstep, the customer isn't thinking about warehouse operations. They're thinking about the brand they purchased from. Our responsibility is to help ensure that experience reflects positively on the brand every single time. The Goal Isn't Shipping Boxes. It's Creating Confidence. Fulfillment is often viewed as an operational function. In reality, it's a customer experience function. The best fulfillment operations create confidence—for customers waiting for their orders, for brands managing growth, and for teams responsible for delivering consistent results. Every order that moves through a Barrett facility represents a commitment to operational excellence, continuous improvement, and customer satisfaction. The journey from warehouse shelf to doorstep may happen behind the scenes, but its impact is felt with every successful delivery.

Celebrating 20 Years of The Great Game of Business at Barrett

By Faith Artieda • May 28, 2026

This year marks an important milestone for Barrett Distribution — 20 years of participating in The Great Game of Business® (GGOB) , a program that has helped shape our culture, strengthen employee engagement, and create a stronger sense of teamwork and shared success across the organization. Over the past two decades, GGOB has become much more than a business program at Barrett. It has become part of the way we communicate, collaborate, and grow together as a company. Through open-book management principles, weekly huddles, forecasting, scoreboards, and Mini Games, employees across Barrett locations have had the opportunity to better understand the business and actively contribute to its success. One of the most meaningful impacts of GGOB has been the way it brings people together. In an industry built on precision, service, and operational excellence, collaboration is essential. Barrett’s success depends on teams working together across departments, facilities, and regions — and GGOB has helped strengthen those connections by creating a culture centered around communication, accountability, and involvement. GGOB encourages employees to think beyond their individual roles and understand how their work impacts customers, coworkers, and overall company performance. Whether it’s improving warehouse efficiency, supporting transportation operations, enhancing customer service, or identifying process improvements, employees are empowered to contribute ideas and solutions that help move Barrett forward. As Tim Barret, Founder of Barrett, states, "...we share all of the financial results with all of the employees, and they have a vested interest since they will receive a payout result." That sense of involvement creates stronger engagement across the organization. Employees are not simply completing daily tasks — they are participating in the success of the business. By understanding company goals and key performance drivers, teams are able to work together with a shared purpose and celebrate accomplishments collectively. Community and collaboration have always been important values at Barrett, and GGOB has helped reinforce those values over the last 20 years. The program creates opportunities for employees to learn from one another, support one another, and recognize the impact each person has on the organization. It encourages transparency and open communication, helping employees feel more connected to leadership, their teams, and the company’s long-term vision. As Barrett has continued to grow nationwide, maintaining a strong culture has remained a priority. GGOB has played an important role in helping preserve the family-oriented environment that Barrett is known for, even as the company has expanded operations and welcomed new employees across the country. The program helps create consistency in communication and engagement while keeping employees connected to the bigger picture. To help celebrate this 20-year anniversary, Barrett owner Tim Barrett recently participated in a video discussion reflecting on the company’s GGOB journey and the impact it has had on Barrett over the years. The conversation highlighted how collaboration, employee involvement, and shared accountability continue to contribute to the company’s success today. This milestone is ultimately a celebration of the people who make Barrett successful every day. The dedication, teamwork, creativity, and commitment shown by employees across the organization are what continue to drive Barrett forward. Twenty years later, The Great Game of Business continues to strengthen the culture of collaboration and engagement that makes Barrett special — and the future of the game is stronger than ever.